Char-Broil Turkey Air Fryer Review: Is It Worth It?

The Char-Broil turkey air fryer is The Big Easy, a propane-powered outdoor cooker that roasts a whole turkey with no oil. The 16,000 BTU burner handles birds up to 16 lb (7.3 kg). Char-Broil lists the cooker at $149.99, and the unit works outdoors only on a 20 lb (9 kg) propane tank.
Testers found the turkey juicy with crisp skin, close to deep-fried results. A bird takes about 10 minutes per pound. Setup is quick and cleanup is simple. Wind can blow out the flame, and the basket can trap wings and legs. The cooker also removes hot oil, which is the main danger of turkey frying.
The Big Easy suits holiday cooks with a patio and a propane tank. Cooks without outdoor space, or with a love for batter-fried food, should look elsewhere. The sections below cover cooking times, safety, price, and cleaning, then give a clear verdict on whether the cooker earns its spot.
What Is the Char-Broil Turkey Air Fryer?
The Char-Broil turkey air fryer is a propane-powered outdoor cooker sold as The Big Easy Outdoor Air Fryer. The 16,000 BTU unit roasts a whole turkey without oil. Earlier versions carried the name oil-less turkey fryer, but the basic design stayed the same.
The model name causes real confusion. Why? Char-Broil also sells a Smoker-Roaster Grill under the Big Easy name. The grill has a lid and a temperature control. The oil-less fryer has neither, so recipes written for one do not always fit the other.
Outdoor use is the only approved setting. The cooker runs on a 20 lb (9 kg) propane tank, which is sold separately. A patio, deck, or driveway with open air around it is the right place to set it up.
Is It Really an Air Fryer?
No. J. Kenji López-Alt of Serious Eats called it an outdoor propane vertical roaster, not a fryer. Frying needs hot fat, and the Big Easy uses none. So why the air fryer label? The label describes the result more than the method.
The infrared claim gets the same treatment. López-Alt pointed out that all radiative heat is infrared, whether it comes from an oven, a broiler, or the sun. To be clear, the marketing term adds little beyond the fact that the drum gets very hot.
Owners on a barbecue forum reach a similar view. Several describe the cooker as a small, efficient convection-style oven. The heat surrounds the meat in a tight circle, which runs hotter than a kitchen oven and cooks evenly.
How Does the Char-Broil Turkey Air Fryer Work?
The Big Easy heats the gap between two metal cylinders with a propane burner. A steel outer cylinder wraps a smaller aluminum inner cylinder. Heat fills the space between them and radiates inward toward the food.
The turkey sits in a basket that lowers into the center of the drum. Hot surfaces surround the bird on every side. Why does that matter? The layout crisps skin all the way around instead of only on the top.
Controls stay simple. A cook connects the propane tank, turns one knob, and the piezo ignition lights the burner. The same knob adjusts power afterward. After that, the cook mostly waits for the meat to reach temperature.
The top of the drum stays open. A cook can watch the skin turn golden through the whole cook. A metal grate serves as a lid for the final 15 minutes to deepen the color.
What Comes in the Box?
The box holds the cooker, a cooking basket, a lifting hook, a drip tray, and a meat thermometer. A metal grate also ships inside and works as both a lid and a heat deflector.
Assembly takes about 15 minutes, so there's no big project here. Handles, legs, and the piezo ignition attach with the included screws, and the grease tray slides in underneath. A Phillips screwdriver covers the tools needed.
At the same time, the unit weighs 28.88 lb (13.1 kg) and measures 20.75 x 23.5 x 16.25 inches (53 x 60 x 41 cm). Two side handles make carrying manageable. Owners have taken it camping and tailgating.
In the Box:
- Cooking basket
- Lifting hook
- Drip tray
- Meat thermometer
- Metal grate lid and heat deflector
What Can You Cook in It?
The Big Easy cooks a 16 lb (7.3 kg) turkey or chicken, an 8 lb (3.6 kg) roast, or a 6 lb (2.7 kg) pork shoulder. Char-Broil lists those limits for the 16,000 BTU burner.
Testers pushed well past poultry. One cook finished a pork belly slab in 1 hour. Another roasted fajita peppers and flank steak, then butternut squash and Brussels sprouts in 1 hour. Owners also report prime rib and ribs.
Batter is the one hard limit. Why? Wet batter drips and does not set, so beer-battered fish is out. Onion rings dredged in flour come out crispy, though not as crispy as oil-fried versions.
Capacity by Food:
| Food | Maximum Size | Tested Time |
|---|---|---|
| Turkey or chicken | 16 lb (7.3 kg) | 90 minutes to 2 hours 50 minutes |
| Roast | 8 lb (3.6 kg) | Not tested |
| Pork shoulder | 6 lb (2.7 kg) | Not tested |
| Pork belly slab | One slab | 1 hour |
How Big a Turkey Fits?
Char-Broil lists 16 lb (7.3 kg) as the maximum turkey size. A bird near that weight fills the basket and leaves little spare room around it.
Some owners stretch the limit. One cook put a 20 lb (9 kg) brined bird in the drum and finished in about 4 hours. The result was the best turkey that owner had cooked, but the fit is tight.
The standard basket makes big birds awkward. Here's why: wings and legs can catch in the cage during removal. A hinged or collapsible basket makes loading and lifting far easier.
Does the Char-Broil Turkey Air Fryer Actually Work?
Yes. The Big Easy produces a juicy turkey with crisp skin in under three hours. Popular Mechanics cooked a 13.83 lb (6.3 kg) pre-brined bird and found the inside incredibly juicy with a crisp, lightly charred outside.
Serious Eats reached a similar conclusion about the cooking itself. López-Alt called it a fantastic cooker. The bird cooks from all sides at once, so every inch of skin crisps, and dropping a turkey in a hole beats flipping one in an oven.
What's more, owners who have used it for years agree. Descriptions include tender, moist meat and crunchy skin. One owner reports three years of use with no problems.
One limit remains. The cooker uses no oil, so does the bird match true deep-fried richness? No. The bird lacks the richness of true deep-fried turkey. The balance of crisp and tender still impressed the Popular Mechanics tester.
How Does the Turkey Taste?
The turkey tastes as juicy as a roast bird and moister than a deep-fried one. In the Serious Eats side-by-side test, juiciness matched the roast, and the breast meat beat the fried turkey for moisture and tenderness.
Skin lands in the middle. How close is it to deep-fried? The skin was better than the roast bird's. The actual deep-fried turkey still won on crackling crispness, but the gap was small.
A forum owner who used to deep fry a turkey every year no longer does. The results, skin included, are close enough that dealing with oil is not worth it.
A small trick closes the flavor gap. Painting the bird with peanut oil before cooking adds some oil taste without the cleanup. Experienced owners call the step optional.
How Long Does a Turkey Take?
A turkey needs about 10 minutes per pound (22 minutes per kilogram). One 16 lb bird finished in exactly 160 minutes in 30 degree (-1 C) weather with a light breeze.
Results vary between cooks. For example, a 13 lb (5.9 kg) bird took 2 hours 50 minutes, a 12 lb (5.4 kg) bird took 2 hours 15 minutes, and a 14 lb (6.4 kg) bird finished in 90 minutes in another test.
Doneness targets differ too, and the numbers matter. Two testers pulled the bird at 165 F (74 C) in the breast. A longtime owner cooks to 180 F (82 C) in the thighs and 170 F (77 C) in the breast and probes several spots.
Resting matters after the cook. Testers rested the bird for 15 to 30 minutes before carving, and the juices stayed in the meat.
Tested Cook Times:
| Bird Weight | Cook Time | Finish Temperature |
|---|---|---|
| 12 lb (5.4 kg) | 2 hours 15 minutes | Not stated |
| 13 lb (5.9 kg) | 2 hours 50 minutes | 165 F (74 C) |
| 14 lb (6.4 kg) | 90 minutes | 165 F (74 C) |
| 16 lb (7.3 kg) | 160 minutes | 170-180 F (77-82 C) |
What Are the Downsides?
The biggest downside is awkward food removal. Wings and legs can stick in the cage, which makes lifting the finished turkey harder than loading it.
The cooker serves one main purpose. López-Alt warned that people who hate unitaskers would likely see it collect dust 364 days a year. The outdoor-only rule and storage size add to the problem.
Frying limits apply as well. No batter means no beer-battered fish and no tempura. Owners who love those foods keep a separate fryer.
An older review mentioned a long assembly and some sharp edges. Later testers found setup quick, so the complaint may reflect older models or a first-time builder.
Main Downsides:
- Wings and legs stick in the basket
- Wind can blow out the flame
- Single main purpose
- No wet-batter frying
Does Wind Affect It?
Yes. Wind can blow out the burner flame on the open-top drum. Strong gusts killed the flame twice during the Popular Mechanics test.
The good news? Relighting took little time. The tester still shielded the unit with a metal guard halfway through the cook to keep the flame steady.
Does a lid fix the problem? The grate lid helps on breezy days. Char-Broil suggests the lid for the last 15 minutes. A lid also retains heat in wind, though a mild day with a lid on risks burning the meat.
Is It Safer Than Deep Frying?
Yes. The Big Easy removes hot oil, the main hazard of a traditional turkey fryer. No pot of oil means no spill, no boil-over, and no leftover oil to dispose of.
But an open propane flame still needs respect. The drum gets very hot, and the cooker belongs outdoors on a level surface. Safer than oil does not mean risk-free.
And oil costs money too. An older write-up put peanut oil for a traditional fry at $35 to $40 per use. The Big Easy skips that expense on every cook.
Why Do Fire Officials Warn Against Turkey Fryers?
The National Fire Protection Association does not recommend using turkey fryers at all. The group reports that Thanksgiving sees about three times the daily average number of home cooking fires.
The cause is simple physics. A partly frozen or wet turkey hits hot oil, and the water turns to steam. What happens next? Steam expands fast and throws oil out of the pot.
Oil can also overheat to the point of combustion when the pot has no thermostat. Spills, unstable stands, and overfilled pots add to the danger. The Big Easy avoids the oil problem entirely.
How Much Does It Cost?
The Big Easy lists for $149.99 at Char-Broil. Popular Mechanics saw $150 at Amazon and Walmart and $160 at Lowe's.
Older coverage quoted $99, and some retailers still list that figure for earlier models. Did prices change? Prices have risen since those reviews appeared.
Accessories add to the bill. The 22-piece kit costs $25.99, grease tray liners cost $5.99, and the bunk bed basket costs $9.99. A custom cover runs $25.99.
Fuel is a separate purchase. The cooker needs a 20 lb (9 kg) propane tank, which Char-Broil does not include.
Typical Costs:
| Item | Price |
|---|---|
| Big Easy cooker (current list) | $149.99 |
| 22-piece accessory kit | $25.99 |
| Bunk bed basket | $9.99 |
| Grease tray liners | $5.99 |
Is It Worth the Price?
Yes, for the right cook. The Big Easy pays back its cost through savings on oil and oven space. No oil purchase or disposal removes a recurring cost for fried-style turkey.
Oven space is the other payoff. Here's the thing: on a holiday, the oven fills with casseroles and sides. A cooker that runs outside frees the oven for them.
A one-year limited warranty covers the unit. Does the build hold up? Owner reports of multi-year use suggest it does.
Now, the math fails for rare use. A cook who roasts one turkey every few years may never recover $150. Frequent holiday cooks get the best return.
How Hard Is It to Clean?
Cleaning is easy because the cooker burns off its own residue. In plain English, the cook removes the food after cooking and lets the burner run for 10 to 15 minutes. Buildup cooks away.
The basket needs only soap and water in the sink when buildup collects. Nothing else in the drum needs scrubbing.
The grease tray sits at the front for easy access. The cook waits for the unit to cool, then empties the tray.
Cleaning Steps:
- Remove the food from the basket.
- Let the burner run for 10 to 15 minutes to burn off buildup.
- Turn the cooker off and let it cool.
- Empty the front grease tray.
- Wash the basket with soap and water if needed.
Does the Grease Tray Need Special Care?
Yes, a little. Disposable aluminum liners keep the grease tray clean with almost no effort. A pack of liners costs $5.99, and the cook drops one in and throws it away afterward.
Drippings split opinion, and that's fair. One owner makes gravy from them every year, and pulls the tray partway through the cook. Another cook boils the drippings first, or skips them when in doubt.
First-time seasoning also matters. Testers coated the inside of the drum with vegetable oil and burned it off before the first cook. The step helps the unit reach higher temperatures, and performance improves with use.
Is the Char-Broil Turkey Air Fryer Worth It?
Short answer: yes, for holiday cooks. The Big Easy delivers fried-style turkey without oil at a fair price. Juicy meat, crisp skin, quick setup, one-knob control, and a weight under 30 lb (13.6 kg) make up the upside.
The bad news? The cons are real but manageable. Wind blows out the flame, the basket traps wings and legs, the cooker does one main job, and the 16 lb cap limits the bird.
Pros:
- Juicy meat
- Crisp skin
- No oil to buy or dispose of
- Quick setup
- One-knob control
The tradeoff favors the cook who serves turkey or roasts a few times a year. Pros outweigh cons for that cook. For anyone else, the cooker is an expensive extra.
Who Should Skip It?
Cooks without outdoor space should skip the Big Easy. The cooker runs on propane and belongs outside only. An apartment with no patio rules it out.
Anyone who dislikes single-purpose gear should also pass. The unit stores as a bulky drum and sees heavy use only a few times a year.
Bottom line: fans of batter-fried food need a real fryer. Wet batter does not work in the Big Easy, so fish and tempura stay off the menu.
Pop Kitchen is a reader-supported platform. Purchases made through our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.
