Insignia Air Fryer Review: Is It Worth It?

Insignia stainless steel digital air fryer with the headline Insignia Air Fryer Review

The Insignia air fryer is a budget countertop appliance sold at Best Buy. It cooks with circulating hot air and little oil, so frozen snacks crisp up fast. Sizes run from 3.4 to 10 quarts (3.2 to 9.5 liters), and prices start near $25 on sale. Two large recalls changed how buyers see the line.

The line mixes knob and digital models with presets, auto shut-off, and dishwasher-safe baskets. Owners praise the roomy basket and crisp frozen food. One owner also reported a handle that loosens. Recalls in 2022 and 2024 followed fire and melting reports. Ninja and Chefman cost a little more and show stronger ratings from thousands of buyers.

Safety decides this review. The sections below explain which models were recalled, what to do with one, and how the costs stack up. They also weigh the pros against the cons, one by one. The final verdict says which buyers fit an Insignia air fryer and which buyers walk away.

What Is an Insignia Air Fryer?

An Insignia air fryer is a countertop appliance that circulates hot air to crisp food with little or no oil. Best Buy sells the line under the Insignia name. Models range from compact basket fryers to large air fryer ovens.

The range covers cooking chambers from about 3.4 to 10 quarts (3.2 to 9.5 liters). Bodies come in plastic or plastic with stainless steel. Finishes are black or stainless steel.

Price defines the brand. Why does it matter so much? One owner picked up the 3.4-quart (3.2 L) model for $25 during a flash sale. A retailer lists the digital 3.4-quart version at $49.

Which Insignia Air Fryer Models Are Available?

Insignia sells basket air fryers from 3.4 to 5 quarts, a dual-basket 8-quart model, and a 10-quart air fryer oven. Both digital and knob-controlled versions exist. Model numbers sit on a label under each unit.

The 3.4-quart NS-AF34D2 has a digital panel, a 180F to 400F (82C to 204C) range, and ten presets. A non-stick cooking tray and user guide ship in the box.

The 5-quart stainless digital model measures 14.8 inches (37.6 cm) deep, 12.4 inches (31.5 cm) wide, and 12.8 inches (32.5 cm) high. Consumer Reports claims 1700 watts for the NS-AF5DSS2 and weighs it at 13 pounds (5.9 kg).

The 10-quart air fryer oven comes as the NS-AF10DSS2 in stainless steel. Knob-controlled 5-quart units such as the NS-AF53MSS0 and NS-AF5MSS2 cover the simpler end of the range.

Insignia Models at a Glance:

ModelCapacityControls
NS-AF34D23.4 quarts (3.2 L)Digital
NS-AF5DSS25 quarts claimed, 3.9 quarts measuredDigital
NS-AF10DSS210 quartsDigital oven
NS-AF53MSS05 quartsKnob

How Does an Insignia Air Fryer Work?

An Insignia air fryer circulates hot air around the food to form a crispy outer layer while moisture stays inside. The method needs little to no oil. So where does the crunch come from? It comes from moving hot air, not from a pot of hot oil.

The 3.4-quart model holds a temperature range from 180F to 400F (82C to 204C). The range handles roasting, baking, and frying. Frozen snacks, chicken, and vegetables all fit inside that window.

The basic knob design has only three parts. The base unit holds the heating system. A drawer slides in, and the basket sits inside the drawer. A push button, covered by a sliding piece of plastic, releases the basket.

What Features Do Insignia Air Fryers Have?

Digital Insignia models offer ten presets: toast, pizza, French fries, steaks and chops, fish and shrimp, chicken, cake, rotisserie, dehydrate, and preheat. Each preset loads a ready-made time and temperature. The presets remove the guesswork from common foods.

An auto shut-off timer runs from 0 to 60 minutes. What happens when the timer ends? The unit stops on its own. And a keep-warm function holds food at the chosen temperature afterward.

Knob models skip the screen. One knob sets temperature and the other sets time. The time dial is an old-school egg-timer type that ticks and then dings.

What's more, the basket and pan on the 3.4-quart digital model are dishwasher-safe. Cleanup takes one trip through the machine. And no leftover oil needs disposal.

Starting a unit takes three steps. Plug it in, set the temperature and time (or pick a preset), and press start. Pull the basket out when the timer dings.

What Do Insignia Air Fryer Reviews Say?

Insignia air fryer reviews praise the low price and everyday cooking results while flagging build details and the recalls. Owners of working units mostly describe simple, dependable snack cooking. Safety news shapes the rest of the conversation.

Ratings stay middling. The 5-quart stainless digital listing on Amazon holds 3.8 stars across 22 ratings. Is 3.8 stars a reliable score? Not really, because the sample is small.

Consumer Reports tests air fryers on controls, convenience, cleaning, and noise. The Insignia NS-AF5DSS2 score sits behind a membership wall. Top-scoring air fryers in that program reach 78 points.

What Do Owners Like?

Owners like the roomy basket, the crisp frozen foods, and the price. One owner found the basket bigger than expected for the cost. It held four chicken thighs.

For example, frozen mozzarella sticks, French fries, and sweet plantains all came out well. The plantains even picked up the small crispy bits that make them worth eating.

Reheating earns extra praise. How does it handle leftovers? Ribs, chicken, and steak reheat much better than in a microwave. The air fryer also beats the oven on convenience.

Value closes the list. The same owner judged the air fryer worth at least twice the $25 sale price.

What Owners Like:

  • Roomy basket
  • Crisp frozen snacks
  • Better reheating than a microwave
  • Low price

What Are the Common Complaints?

The most specific complaint targets the two screws and nuts that hold the handle to the basket. They needed tightening almost every week across three months of ownership. The owner named these screws as the likeliest part to fail.

Is the loose handle fixable? Yes. All-metal lock washers under the screws stopped the loosening for three weeks and counting. The repair costs pennies, but the owner has to do the work.

Capacity claims also drew attention. Consumer Reports measured 3.9 quarts (3.7 liters) of usable space on a model sold as a 5-quart unit.

The bad news? The recalls form the largest complaint by far. Two separate notices for fire, melting, and burn hazards follow the brand around.

Why Were Insignia Air Fryers Recalled?

Insignia air fryers were recalled because the units can overheat, catch fire, melt, or burn the user. Best Buy issued the first recall in April 2022. A second, separate recall followed in March 2024.

The 2022 recall covered more than 600,000 air fryers and air fryer ovens. About 635,000 units sold in the United States and 137,000 in Canada. Best Buy logged more than 100 reports of fires or melting. Two people were injured. One was a child.

The 2024 recall covered more than 250,000 Insignia units across the United States and Canada. The hazards listed were fire, burn, and laceration.

What did both notices tell owners to do first? Stop using the unit immediately.

Is Your Insignia Air Fryer Part of the Recall?

Yes. Your air fryer is part of the 2022 recall when its model number is NS-AF32DBK9, NS-AF32MBK9, NS-AF50MBK9, NS-AF53DSS0, NS-AF53MSS0, NS-AF55DBK9, NS-AFO6DBK1, or NS-AFO6DSS1. Any other number needs a check against the 2024 notice.

The brand name Insignia appears on the top or front of each unit. A rating label on the underside shows the brand and the model number.

The 2024 recall spans chamber sizes of about 3.4 to 10 quarts (3.2 to 9.5 liters). Model numbers appear on a label underneath each unit. Owners compare that label with the official notice.

2022 Recalled Models:

  • NS-AF32DBK9
  • NS-AF32MBK9
  • NS-AF50MBK9
  • NS-AF53DSS0
  • NS-AF53MSS0
  • NS-AF55DBK9
  • NS-AFO6DBK1
  • NS-AFO6DSS1

What Should You Do With a Recalled Insignia Air Fryer?

An owner of a recalled unit stops using it immediately. Unplug it. Why the rush? Continued use carries the fire and burn risk that triggered the recall.

The 2022 remedy was store credit from Best Buy. Owners registered at the recall website or called Best Buy at 800-566-7498, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. ET, Monday through Friday.

The 2024 remedy works differently. Owners submit images of the damaged unit online. They then receive a refund check or store credit. The unit doesn't go back to a Best Buy store.

Recall Steps:

  1. Stop using the air fryer immediately.
  2. Unplug the unit.
  3. For the 2022 recall, register at the recall website or call Best Buy at 800-566-7498.
  4. For the 2024 recall, submit images of the damaged unit online.
  5. Collect the refund check or store credit.

Is an Insignia Air Fryer Safe?

No. A recalled Insignia air fryer is unsafe to use. Fire, melting, and burn reports drove both recalls.

Units outside the recall lists are not named in those notices. To be clear, only the listed Insignia models are affected, and other brands have no connection to them.

Air fryers in general run safely under normal care. Read the manual first. Unplug the unit when idle, and stay nearby while it cooks.

Is Insignia a Reliable Brand?

No. Insignia carries a mixed reliability record. Recalls in 2022 and again in 2024 weigh heavily on trust.

Consumer Reports lists a one-year warranty on the NS-AF5DSS2. Coverage lasts one year, so a late failure falls outside it.

Build quality adds one more weak point. One owner re-tightened the basket handle almost every week.

How Does Insignia Compare to Ninja and Chefman?

Insignia undercuts Ninja and Chefman on price but trails both on review volume and safety history. Ninja and Chefman each show 4.6 stars or higher from thousands of buyers.

The Ninja Air Fryer Pro XL 5-quart (AF140) starts at $79.97 with 7,504 reviews at 4.6 stars. The Ninja AF141 5-quart holds 4.7 stars across 7,982 ratings.

Chefman sells a 6-quart, 1500-watt model for $59.98. It shows 4.6 stars from 13,000 reviews. A 5-quart Chefman sells near $80.

Budget rivals also score well in lab tests. The Dash Tasti-Crisp ($47.99) and Amazon Basics ($67.48) both scored 78 at Consumer Reports. The Chefman RJ38-2T, from $42.43, scored 77.

Price and Rating Comparison:

ModelPriceRating
Ninja Air Fryer Pro XL (AF140)From $79.974.6 stars
Chefman 6-quart, 1500 W$59.984.6 stars
Dash Tasti-Crisp$47.9978 (Consumer Reports)
Amazon Basics$67.4878 (Consumer Reports)
Chefman RJ38-2TFrom $42.4377 (Consumer Reports)

Which Is Better, Insignia or Ninja?

Ninja is the stronger pick for most buyers because of its review volume and ratings. Thousands of buyers rate Ninja models at 4.6 to 4.7 stars. The 5-quart Insignia listing on Amazon holds only 22 ratings.

Where does Insignia win? Only on entry price. The knob models stay simple, and a $25 to $49 price sits well below Ninja.

The tradeoff is clear. Ninja costs more upfront. Insignia saves money but carries recall history.

How Much Does an Insignia Air Fryer Cost?

An Insignia air fryer costs between $25 and $120 depending on size and where it sells. The 3.4-quart digital model lists at $49. One owner paid $25 on a flash sale.

Consumer Reports lists the 5-quart NS-AF5DSS2 at $120.00. How does that stack up? The price sits above several rivals that score 78 in lab tests.

Here is the kicker: competitors cost less for the same capacity class. The Dash Tasti-Crisp at $47.99 and the Chefman RJ38-2T from $42.43 both score as high as 78 in lab testing.

How Much Does It Cost to Run?

An Insignia NS-AF5DSS2 costs about $4.77 a year to run at one hour a week. The estimate assumes 350F (177C) and 52 weeks of use.

Consumer Reports claims a 1700-watt draw for the same model. Heavy daily use multiplies the yearly figure, but the base cost stays small.

Is the Insignia Air Fryer Worth It?

Yes. The Insignia air fryer is worth it only as a cheap, non-recalled unit. Short answer: the pros are real, and so are the cons.

The pros: a low price, a roomy basket, good frozen-food results, and easy knob controls. All four match owner experience.

Pros:

  • Low price
  • Roomy basket
  • Good frozen-food results
  • Easy knob controls

The cons: two recalls, handle screws that loosen, and a 5-quart claim measured at 3.9 quarts (3.7 liters). Each con hits long-term trust.

Cons:

  • Two recalls
  • Handle screws that loosen
  • 5-quart claim measured at 3.9 quarts

Bottom line: the balance favors rivals. Ninja and Chefman cost $60 to $80 and carry stronger ratings.

Who Should Buy an Insignia Air Fryer?

A budget shopper buys an Insignia air fryer only after checking the model number against both recall lists. That buyer wants a basic air fryer under $50 and accepts the recall history.

In plain English: everyone else is better off elsewhere. Buyers who want proven long-term reliability, or who can spend $60 to $80 on a Ninja or Chefman, get a safer bet.

Pop Kitchen is a reader-supported platform. Purchases made through our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.