Martha Stewart Air Fryer Review: Is It Worth It?

Black Martha Stewart French door air fryer oven next to the headline Martha Stewart Air Fryer Review

The Martha Stewart air fryer is a line of countertop air fryers from the first small appliance collection Martha Stewart launched in April 2026. The flagship is a 34 quart French door air fryer toaster oven. A 6 quart slim basket model sits beside it for smaller counters, so buyers can pick the size that fits their kitchen.

The oven packs 1,700 watts, five heating elements and 12 presets behind two French doors. The unit preheats quickly and can replace a toaster oven, an air fryer and a rotisserie. Owners praise the capacity and the design. Drawbacks include a large footprint, a basket that sits on the rack and a delayed interior light.

Prices run from $199.99 on sale to $299.99 at list, and the slim model costs $99.99. The review covers features, performance, drawbacks, comparisons, price and where to buy. It closes with a clear verdict on who should buy the oven and who should skip it, so you can decide quickly.

What Is the Martha Stewart Air Fryer?

The Martha Stewart air fryer is a line of countertop air fryers from Martha Stewart's first small appliance collection, launched in April 2026. The range includes a 34 quart French door air fryer toaster oven and a 6 quart slim basket model.

The collection arrived exclusively on Amazon and covers more than air fryers. The collection also holds a rice cooker, a slow cooker, a stand mixer, a blender, a kettle, a toaster and a griddle. Clean lines and soft colors make the pieces look display-worthy.

Search results for the keyword mostly point to the French door oven. Why does that matter? That model draws the most attention, so this review centers on it and flags where the slim basket model differs.

Which Martha Stewart Air Fryer Models Exist?

The Martha Stewart lineup has two main air fryers: a 34 quart French door oven and a 6 quart slim basket model. The oven is the flagship. The slim model suits smaller counters.

The oven offers 12 cooking functions, such as bake, broil, roast and dehydrate. The slim model offers six presets, a digital touchscreen and shake reminders. Its nonstick basket is PFAS-free.

Colors vary by model. Listings show Linen Cream, Caviar Gray and Indigo for the oven. The wider collection also uses Honeydew Green and Sky Blue.

What Features Does the Martha Stewart French Door Oven Have?

The oven packs 1,700 watts, five stainless-steel heating elements and a dual-speed convection fan into a 34 quart cavity. Maximum temperature reaches 450°F (232°C).

Key Specs:

SpecDetail
Capacity34 quarts
Power1,700 watts
Heating elements5 stainless steel
Max temperature450°F (232°C)
Cooking functions12

Two French doors open outward instead of dropping down. They give a clear view of the food. The long door swing that eats counter space in front of the unit disappears. Why does that matter? A drop-down door needs that clearance, and French doors do not.

Controls pair an LED display with dials. The toast function lets you pick a darkness level instead of guessing a time. Here's the kicker: that detail helps anyone who has burned toast in a basic toaster oven.

How Does the Martha Stewart Air Fryer Oven Work?

The oven cooks by circulating hot air from five heating elements with a dual-speed fan. Elements sit on the top, bottom, rear and side. The fan moves heat evenly. Why does that matter? Even heat shortens preheating and crisps surfaces.

Twelve presets set the mode with one touch. Each preset matches a common task, from toast and bagel to pizza, proof and slow cook.

The 12 Presets:

  • Bake
  • Broil
  • Air fry
  • Roast
  • Toast
  • Bagel
  • Pizza
  • Proof
  • Slow cook
  • Dehydrate
  • Cookies
  • Reheat

Air frying runs at up to 450°F (232°C). Heat at that level crisps wings, fries and roasted vegetables without a separate deep fryer or standalone air fryer.

What Accessories Come With the Martha Stewart Oven?

The oven ships with a baking tray, an air fry basket, an oven rack, a crumb tray and a rotisserie spit. The spit is rated for a whole chicken.

Included Accessories:

  • Baking tray
  • Air fry basket
  • Oven rack
  • Crumb tray
  • Rotisserie spit

Most toaster ovens at this price skip the rotisserie. So what does that mean for you? The extra sets the Martha Stewart model apart from many rivals.

The accessories use a ceramic nonstick finish. They tolerate a dishwasher, but hand washing protects the coating longer.

Does the Martha Stewart Air Fryer Actually Work Well?

Yes. The oven handles air frying, baking, toasting and roasting well enough to replace several appliances. And owners report that it preheats faster than comparable air fryer ovens.

Capacity helps. Why does it matter? The cavity toasts six slices of bread, bakes a 12 inch (30 cm) pizza or holds a whole chicken. A family of four can use it as a second oven for sides and sheet-pan dinners.

For example, home recipes confirm the range. Chicken wings crisp at 400°F (204°C) in 20 to 25 minutes with a flip halfway. A 12 inch (30 cm) pizza bakes at 450°F (232°C) in 10 to 14 minutes.

Is the Martha Stewart Air Fryer as Crispy as a Basket Air Fryer?

No. A dedicated basket air fryer still crisps food slightly faster and harder than the Martha Stewart oven. Wings, vegetables and frozen foods come out well, but the finish is moderate on some foods.

The air fry basket does not slide into rails. What does that mean in practice? The basket sits on the oven rack or baking tray, which differs from a dedicated basket unit.

Rack placement and temperature take a short learning curve. Owners who adjust both get crisp frozen fries, nuggets and wings.

Is the Martha Stewart Air Fryer Easy to Use?

Yes. Presets and dials make the oven approachable even for first-time air fryer owners. Setting a mode and a temperature takes a few turns of a dial.

The truth is, feedback on controls is mixed. Some owners cook to perfection. Others struggle with the controls and report uneven cooking.

The good news? Cleanup stays simple. Parts come out, the interior has a nonstick coating and parchment paper helps with messy foods. Empty the crumb tray after every use to prevent smoke and odors.

What Are the Downsides of the Martha Stewart Air Fryer?

The oven has four main drawbacks: a large footprint, a basket that does not slide on rails, a delayed interior light and a very hot exterior. None breaks the appliance, but each affects daily use.

Main Drawbacks:

  • Large footprint
  • Basket sits on the rack
  • Interior light turns on only when the timer ends
  • Very hot exterior

The interior light switches on only when the cook timer ends. The light stays off when you open the door mid-cook. So how do you check the food? The clear doors do that job instead.

This is important: the outside gets extremely hot during cooking. Clear the counter space around the unit before you start.

Does the Martha Stewart Air Fryer Take Up Too Much Counter Space?

Yes, for small kitchens. The oven measures 13.5 by 17.5 by 14.5 inches (34 by 44 by 37 cm) and needs about 18 inches (46 cm) of free counter width.

Small households and tight kitchens struggle to justify the space. Who does the size suit instead? Families of three to six who cook large batches.

The 6 quart slim model solves the problem. The slim model is built to take less counter space while keeping a touchscreen and six presets.

How Does the Martha Stewart Air Fryer Compare With Other Air Fryer Ovens?

The oven sits in the extra-large class of French door air fryer ovens, with more capacity than Emeril and fewer presets. Gourmia's 37 quart model is bigger.

The Martha Stewart oven undercuts the Our Place Wonder Oven Pro on price. The oven still offers more capacity and more presets. Here's why that matters: that price gap is its strongest competitive angle.

By comparison, style is the other edge. Coordinated colors and clean lines suit a kitchen built around a color scheme.

Martha Stewart vs Emeril, Gourmia and Wonder Oven Pro?

The comparison comes down to capacity, presets and price. The table below lines up the four ovens.

Oven Comparison:

ModelCapacityFunctionsTypical Price
Martha Stewart French Door34 quarts12$199.99-$299.99
Emeril Lagasse French Door26 quarts24$109.99-$209.99
Gourmia French Door37 quarts12$139-$180
Our Place Wonder Oven ProAbout 20 quarts8$249-$295

Emeril's 26 quart model lists 24 functions. Many of those are recipe-style variations on the same core modes. Martha Stewart's 12 presets cover the core modes in a bigger cavity.

Gourmia's 37 quart model costs roughly $139 to $180 and offers 12 functions. In plain English: buyers who value size over looks can save money there.

How Much Does the Martha Stewart Air Fryer Cost?

The French door oven lists at $299.99 and commonly sells for around $199.99 during sale events. The drop equals about 33% off. Prime Day deals have pushed it under $200.

Walmart lists the 34 quart oven from $285.06 to $299.39, with the price set by color. The 6 quart slim model costs $99.99 there.

Amazon lists $299.39 for the Indigo oven. Prices shift with launches and promotions. So what should you do? Check the current price before ordering.

Price Snapshot:

RetailerModelPrice
Walmart34 quart oven$285.06-$299.39
Walmart6 quart slim$99.99
Amazon34 quart oven, Indigo$299.39
Sale events34 quart ovenAround $199.99

Where Can You Buy the Martha Stewart Air Fryer?

Buyers can find the Martha Stewart air fryers at Amazon, Walmart, JCPenney, Target and Sur La Table. The model range varies by store.

Amazon launched the line exclusively in April 2026. Is it still Amazon-only? No. Wider retail followed, so guides that still call it Amazon-only are out of date.

Colors differ by seller. Walmart lists Linen Cream and Caviar Gray, while Amazon lists Indigo. Check the color before checkout.

Is the Martha Stewart Air Fryer Worth It?

Yes, for the right buyer. The oven is worth it for families who want one appliance to replace a toaster oven, an air fryer and a rotisserie.

The pros are the French doors, 12 functions, 34 quart capacity, rotisserie and quick preheat. The cons are the big footprint, the basket on the rack, the delayed light and the hot exterior. The pros win near the $199.99 sale price.

Pros:

  • French door design
  • 12 cooking functions
  • 34 quart capacity
  • Rotisserie spit included
  • Quick preheat

Cons:

  • Large footprint
  • Basket sits on the rack
  • Delayed interior light
  • Very hot exterior

Bottom line: ratings back a good, not perfect, verdict. Amazon shows 4.0 stars across 146 ratings. Walmart shows 4.9 stars across 17 reviews. At the full $299.99 list price, the case is closer.

Who Should Skip the Martha Stewart Air Fryer?

Small households and tiny kitchens should skip the 34 quart oven. The footprint overwhelms a small counter and the capacity goes unused.

Crisp-first cooks should choose a dedicated basket air fryer. Those units deliver slightly crispier results, faster.

Buyers who want the style in a compact size can pick the 6 quart slim model at $99.99 instead.

Pop Kitchen is a reader-supported platform. Purchases made through our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.