Ninja Prestige Smart XL Air Fryer Countertop Oven Review: Is It Worth the Price?

Ninja Prestige Smart XL air fryer countertop oven with a roast chicken inside

The Ninja Prestige Smart XL Air Fryer and Countertop Oven (model DT501) is a 10-in-1 stainless steel oven that draws 1,800 watts and air fries, bakes, roasts and toasts. Ninja sells it as an extra-large air fryer for kitchens without a full-size oven. The list price is $329.99 at Amazon, Target and Ninja.

A high-velocity fan and a rear heat source drive the cooking. The cavity fits a 12-pound (5.4 kg) turkey or two 12-inch (30 cm) pizzas at once. Pizza, cookies, toast and fried foods all cook fast and evenly. Air frying runs loud, and the crumb tray demands frequent hand cleaning. Tom's Guide testing found the same strengths and weaknesses.

Big capacity and quick results come with a heavy 33.63-pound (15.3 kg) body and a noisy fan. The Pro DT551 adds a built-in temperature probe for $20 more. Read on for sizes, real test results, cleaning, rival ovens and a final verdict on whether the oven earns its price at $329.99.

What Is the Ninja Prestige Smart XL Air Fryer Countertop Oven?

The Ninja Prestige Smart XL Air Fryer and Countertop Oven is a 10-in-1 stainless steel countertop oven (model DT501) that air fries, bakes, roasts, toasts and dehydrates. The oven draws 1,800 watts. Ninja positions it as an extra-large air fryer for kitchens without a full-size oven.

Tom's Guide testing praised fast, even cooking, a huge capacity and a wide range of functions. The controls are intuitive and work like a full-size oven. The same testing flagged two weak spots. What are they? The oven is challenging to clean and loud while air frying.

Here's the thing: Ninja sells the oven in two versions. The base DT501 skips a temperature probe. The Pro DT551 adds an integrated one. Both carry the Prestige Smart XL name, so the model number matters at checkout.

What Cooking Functions Does It Have?

The oven offers 10 cooking functions: air fry, air roast, broil, bake, whole roast, pizza, toast, bagel, reheat and dehydrate. Each mode loads default temperature and time settings. Cooks adjust both values to suit a recipe.

Cooking Functions:

  • Air fry
  • Air roast
  • Broil
  • Bake
  • Whole roast
  • Pizza
  • Toast
  • Bagel
  • Reheat
  • Dehydrate

To be clear, two extra buttons add control. One switches on the interior light. The other starts two-level cooking for two trays at once. The digital display sits in the door handle.

And toast and bagel modes offer a shade scale from 1 to 7 and a slice count selector. A single rack holds up to 9 slices of toast or 9 bagel halves. Two slices at shade level 4 took about 3 minutes and came out lightly golden.

What Comes in the Box?

The box holds an air fry basket, two sheet pans, two wire racks, a roast tray and a removable crumb tray. The roast tray slots into a sheet pan. The crumb tray slides into the bottom of the oven.

In the Box:

  • Air fry basket
  • Two sheet pans
  • Two wire racks
  • Roast tray
  • Removable crumb tray

The Pro DT551 ships with a Pro Cook thermometer, 15 chef-created recipes and cooking charts. The base DT501 leaves the thermometer out. So pick the version before ordering.

The sheet pans hold 8 to 10 cookies each. A raised lip around the pan edge leaves cookie bottoms slightly uneven. Does that hurt the cookies? Not really. The flaw is cosmetic, and the cookies still tasted delicious.

How Does the Ninja Prestige Smart XL Work?

The oven cooks with Smart Surround Convection, a high-velocity fan paired with a rear heat source. In plain English: hot air surrounds the food from every side. Ninja states that no flipping or shaking is needed.

The control panel lives on the door handle. Labeled buttons cover power, start and stop, function, timer and temperature. Tom's Guide called every button intuitive. The display freezes when the door opens, which blocks accidental changes to a cook cycle.

Ninja claims a 90-second preheat and cooking up to 30% faster than a full-size convection oven. Does the preheat claim hold up? Testing confirmed a quick preheat of around 90 seconds. But cookies still needed a few extra minutes of heat before the oven felt warm enough.

What Does the 2-Level Cooking Button Do?

The 2-level button sets the oven up to cook two trays at the same time. The display lights the best rack positions for the selected function. Ninja promises even results on both levels without rotating, flipping or shaking.

Short answer: real-world fit backs the claim. A 12-inch (30 cm) frozen pizza sits on one rack, and the second rack holds another. Doubling a batch needs no second round.

How Big Is the Ninja Prestige Smart XL?

The oven measures 17.09 inches long, 20.22 inches wide and 13.34 inches tall (43.4 by 51.4 by 33.9 cm). The body weighs 33.63 pounds (15.3 kg). The power cord runs 36 inches (91 cm).

Size and Weight:

SpecMeasurement
Length17.09 inches (43.4 cm)
Width20.22 inches (51.4 cm)
Height13.34 inches (33.9 cm)
Weight33.63 pounds (15.3 kg)
Cord length36 inches (91 cm)

The footprint is large. The oven arrived in a big, heavy box that one tester barely managed to move indoors. Why does that matter? At 20 inches (51 cm) wide, the stainless steel body claims a lot of counter space.

What Can You Fit Inside It?

The cavity fits a turkey up to 12 pounds (5.4 kg). Air frying tops out at 8 pounds (3.6 kg) of food. Bottom line: those two numbers set the ceiling for family-size meals.

Baking space covers two 9 by 9 inch (23 by 23 cm) trays. A single batch holds up to 20 cookies. One rack takes 9 slices of toast or 9 bagel halves.

A 12-inch (30 cm) frozen pizza sits flat on the wire rack. What's more, the second rack adds room for another pizza. Whole chickens fit too.

What Fits Inside:

ItemCapacity
TurkeyUp to 12 pounds (5.4 kg)
Air fry foodUp to 8 pounds (3.6 kg)
Baking traysTwo 9 by 9 inch (23 by 23 cm) trays
CookiesUp to 20 per batch
Toast or bagels9 slices or 9 halves per rack
Frozen pizza12 inches (30 cm), one per rack

How Well Does the Ninja Prestige Smart XL Cook?

The oven cooks fast and evenly across pizza, cookies, toast, chicken and fried foods. Tom's Guide lists fast, even cooking among the top reasons to buy. But a few quirks around crust color and doneness show up in the details.

A 12-inch (30 cm) frozen pizza cooked in 12 minutes at 400°F (204°C) on the pizza setting. The edges crisped and the cheese bubbled. The speed matched a full-size oven. The bottom crust stayed paler than ideal. What fixes that? The tester planned a lower rack next time.

And toast arrives quickly. Two slices of white bread at shade level 4 took around 3 minutes. Both sides turned lightly golden. For darker toast, a higher shade setting does the job.

Does It Air Fry Well?

Yes. The oven air fries tater tots and breaded chicken bites to a crisp, crunchy finish. The fan circulates air around the whole cavity. The mesh air fry basket handles the work.

Salmon needed extra time. Two fillets at 400°F (204°C) for 15 minutes came out underdone. Was the fish ruined? No. Five more minutes cooked the fish through and crisped the exterior. Dripping juices also made the kitchen smell fishy.

The bad news? No mid-cycle shake alarm exists on this oven. The Breville Smart Oven Air Fryer Pro includes one. Tots and chicken bites cooked more evenly after a shake halfway through, so a manual reminder helps.

Does It Bake and Make Pizza Well?

Yes. The oven bakes cookies and pizza well, with only small color quirks. Peanut butter cookies finished in 8 minutes on a single tray. They came out golden brown and cooked through.

Now watch this: heat runs slightly stronger near the door. Cookies at the front browned more than cookies at the back. Rotating the tray for one extra minute fixed the gap. Pizza crust bottoms also stay a little pale.

And roasting suits the oven too. The cavity handles a whole chicken and other large cuts. For serious roasts, the Pro DT551 is the smarter pick because its built-in thermometer tracks doneness as meat cooks.

Is the Ninja Prestige Smart XL Hard to Clean?

Yes. The oven demands frequent hand cleaning, and the crumb tray stains badly when skipped. The removable tray catches drips but needs hand washing. Large stains set after a few uncleaned sessions. Can scrubbing remove them? No. The stains resisted soaking and scrubbing.

Drips don't stop at the tray. Food residue reaches the lower heating elements and makes the oven smell. Salmon juices turned the whole kitchen fishy. Here's why a wipe-down after every use matters: it keeps the oven looking clean.

First use also demands patience. Here is the part most people miss: the manual calls for an empty 20-minute run on air roast at 400°F (204°C). A strong chemical smell filled one test kitchen and pushed an air purifier to a high pollution reading. How long did the smell last? The smell faded after about 15 minutes.

Is It Loud While Air Frying?

Yes. The oven turns significantly louder in air fry mode. Why? The fan that circulates air through the cavity creates the noise. By comparison, bake and roast modes run at a low hum.

The air fry fan sounds noisier than other air fryers tested by Tom's Guide. The noise stays audible and disruptive from the next room. Tom's Guide lists loud air frying among the main reasons to avoid the oven.

How Does the Ninja Prestige Smart XL Compare to Similar Ovens?

The Our Place Wonder Oven is the budget, compact rival at $195. Even so, the smaller body still air fries, bakes, roasts and toasts. Capacity covers one or two servings, well below the Ninja.

The Smeg Countertop Combi Steam Oven costs $999 and adds steam cooking. The Smeg offers 10 functions and 33 preset programs. Its spacious interior excelled across a wide range of tests. So the price puts the Smeg in a different league.

The older Ninja Foodi XL Pro DT201 is the closest sibling. The DT201 also offers 2-level cooking and 1,800 watts of power. The body weighs 26.4 pounds (12 kg), lighter than the 33.63-pound (15.3 kg) Prestige. And sales have run as low as $229.99.

Oven Comparison:

OvenPriceKey Point
Ninja Prestige Smart XL DT501.9910 functions, 2-level cooking, 1,800 watts
Our Place Wonder OvenSmaller footprint, one or two servings
Smeg Countertop Combi Steam OvenSteam cooking, 33 preset programs
Ninja Foodi XL Pro DT201As low as .992-level cooking, 26.4 pounds (12 kg)

What Is the Difference Between the DT501 and DT551?

The DT551 Pro adds a built-in temperature probe for an extra $20. The DT501 skips the probe. Both models carry the Prestige Smart XL name.

The Pro Cook System reads doneness automatically. Ninja describes Auto Temp Detect Intelligence that targets any level from rare to well done at the touch of a button. In plain English: meat roasts finish without guesswork.

The good news? Size stays the same across both versions. Each measures 17.09 by 20.22 by 13.34 inches (43.4 by 51.4 by 33.9 cm). The DT551 weighs 33.75 pounds (15.3 kg) and the DT501 weighs 33.63 pounds (15.3 kg).

DT501 vs DT551:

FeatureDT501DT551
Price.99.99
Temperature probeNoYes
Dimensions17.09 by 20.22 by 13.34 inches17.09 by 20.22 by 13.34 inches
Weight33.63 pounds (15.3 kg)33.75 pounds (15.3 kg)

How Much Does the Ninja Prestige Smart XL Cost?

The Ninja Prestige Smart XL DT501 costs $329.99. Amazon, Target and the Ninja website all charge the same price. The list price sets the baseline for the whole lineup.

The Pro DT551 costs $349.99, an extra $20. What does the extra $20 buy? The probe, which is the only major upgrade. Meat-heavy cooks gain the most from it.

Let me break that down: the Our Place Wonder Oven costs $195. The Smeg Combi Steam Oven costs $999. The Ninja lands in the middle with far more capacity than the Wonder Oven.

Where Can You Buy the Ninja Prestige Smart XL?

The oven sells at Amazon, Target and the Ninja website. Staples, Best Buy, Walmart, QVC, Office Depot and Wayfair also carry Prestige Smart XL models. Retailers use the same product name for both versions.

So check the model number before buying. The DT501 is the base unit and the DT551 is the Pro with the probe. Amazon also sells Renewed units, so confirm the oven is new when full price matters.

Is the Ninja Prestige Smart XL Worth It?

Yes. The oven earns its price for large households that want a full-size oven replacement and an extra-large air fryer in one machine. The $329.99 cost buys fast, even cooking and a huge capacity. The tradeoffs are cleaning effort and noise.

The good news? The strengths are clear. Cooking is fast and even, capacity is extra large, controls are intuitive and the function list is wide. The 90-second preheat and two-level cooking add speed on busy nights.

Pros:

  • Fast, even cooking
  • Extra-large capacity
  • Intuitive controls
  • Wide function list
  • 90-second preheat
  • Two-level cooking

The bad news? The weaknesses are practical. Cleaning is challenging, air frying is loud and the 33.63-pound (15.3 kg) body takes serious counter space. Pizza bottoms stay pale, and no shake alarm exists for fried foods.

Cons:

  • Challenging to clean
  • Loud air frying
  • Heavy 33.63-pound (15.3 kg) body
  • Pale pizza bottoms
  • No shake alarm

Bottom line: it's a strong buy for big households, and roast-heavy cooks gain the most from the extra $20 for the Pro DT551. The built-in probe removes doneness guesswork. Casual air fryer users get less from the added cost.

Who Should Buy the Ninja Prestige Smart XL?

Households without a full-size oven, and cooks who want an extra-large air fryer, gain the most from this oven. The huge capacity feeds a crowd. The wide function list covers pizza, cookies, toast and roasts.

On the flip side, small kitchens, noise-sensitive homes and cooks who dislike scrubbing gain less. The 20-inch (51 cm) width, the loud fan and the hand-wash crumb tray drive that verdict. The compact Our Place Wonder Oven suits tight counters better.

Pop Kitchen is a reader-supported platform. Purchases made through our links may earn us an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you.